| Unique ID issued by UMIN | UMIN000063107 |
|---|---|
| Receipt number | R000072231 |
| Scientific Title | High- versus Low-Level Laser Therapy Combined with Exercise Elicits Outcome- and Population-Specific Responses in Knee Osteoarthritis and Healthy Older Adults |
| Date of disclosure of the study information | 2026/09/29 |
| Last modified on | 2026/11/19 14:09:06 |
High- versus Low-Level Laser Therapy Combined with Exercise Elicits Outcome- and Population-Specific Responses in Knee Osteoarthritis and Healthy Older Adults
HILT vs LLLT Combined with Exercise in Knee Osteoarthritis
High- versus Low-Level Laser Therapy Combined with Exercise Elicits Outcome- and Population-Specific Responses in Knee Osteoarthritis and Healthy Older Adults
High-Intensity Laser Therapy (HILT); Low-Level Laser Therapy (LLLT); Knee Osteoarthritis (KOA)
| Asia(except Japan) |
Knee osteoarthritis (KOA) and healthy older adults
| Geriatrics | Adult |
Others
NO
To compare the effects of high-intensity laser therapy (HILT) and low-level laser therapy (LLLT), combined with the same standardized exercise program, on muscle stiffness, muscle co-activation, balance, and pain-related outcomes in individuals with knee osteoarthritis and healthy older adults, and to determine whether treatment responses differ between the two populations.
Efficacy
Change in muscle stiffness from baseline to 72 hours after the final intervention, assessed by shear wave elastography and expressed as shear wave velocity (SWV, m/s) in the rectus femoris, vastus medialis, vastus lateralis, biceps femoris, semimembranosus, quadriceps tendon, and hamstring tendon.
Interventional
Parallel
Randomized
Individual
Double blind -all involved are blinded
Placebo
YES
NO
NO
Numbered container method
6
Treatment
| Device,equipment | Behavior,custom |
Healthy older adults received high-intensity laser therapy (HILT) using an LMD-LT-30 device at 1064 nm and 5 W. Laser irradiation was applied to five thigh muscle sites using a slow-scanning technique. Each session lasted 30 minutes, three times weekly for 12 weeks (36 sessions), delivering approximately 9000 J per session. Participants also completed standardized supervised functional exercise for 15-20 minutes once weekly for 12 weeks.
Healthy older adults received low-level laser therapy (LLLT) using a BTL-5825SL device at 830 nm and 400 mW. Laser irradiation was applied to the same five thigh muscle sites using a slow-scanning technique. Each session lasted 30 minutes, three times weekly for 12 weeks (36 sessions), delivering approximately 720 J per session. Participants also completed the same standardized supervised functional exercise for 15-20 minutes once weekly for 12 weeks.
Healthy older adults received sham laser treatment using the HILT laser probe with therapeutic output set to 0 W. The guide light and warning sound remained active, but no therapeutic laser irradiation was delivered. The same treatment sites, application procedures, and treatment duration were used. Sham treatment lasted 30 minutes, three times weekly for 12 weeks (36 sessions). Participants also completed standardized supervised functional exercise for 15-20 minutes once weekly for 12 weeks.
Older adults with knee osteoarthritis received high-intensity laser therapy (HILT) using an LMD-LT-30 device at 1064 nm and 5 W. Laser irradiation targeted five predefined thigh muscle sites using a slow-scanning technique. Each session lasted 30 minutes, three times weekly for 12 weeks (36 sessions), delivering approximately 9000 J per session. Participants also completed standardized supervised functional rehabilitation exercises for 15-20 minutes once weekly for 12 weeks.
Older adults with knee osteoarthritis received low-level laser therapy (LLLT) using a BTL-5825SL device at 830 nm and 400 mW. Laser irradiation was applied to the same five thigh muscle sites as the HILT group. Each session lasted 30 minutes, three times weekly for 12 weeks (36 sessions), delivering approximately 720 J per session. Participants also completed the same standardized supervised functional rehabilitation exercises for 15-20 minutes once weekly for 12 weeks.
Older adults with knee osteoarthritis received sham laser treatment using the HILT laser probe with therapeutic output set to 0 W. The guide light and warning sound remained active without therapeutic laser irradiation. The same anatomical sites, scanning procedures, and treatment duration were used. Sham treatment lasted 30 minutes, three times weekly for 12 weeks (36 sessions). Participants also completed standardized supervised functional rehabilitation exercises for 15-20 minutes once weekly for 12 weeks.
| 65 | years-old | <= |
| Not applicable |
Male and Female
Healthy older adults:
1. Aged 65 years or older.
2. Able to walk independently on level ground and negotiate stairs.
3. No clinically significant or persistent hip, knee, or ankle pain.
4. No history of lower-limb surgery or trauma within the previous six months.
5. Willing to participate and provide written informed consent.
Older adults with knee osteoarthritis:
1. Aged 65 years or older and community-dwelling.
2. Diagnosed with knee osteoarthritis according to the American College of Rheumatology criteria.
3. Kellgren-Lawrence grade II or III.
4. Knee osteoarthritis symptoms lasting more than 3 months.
5. Medically stable without severe systemic or major organ disease.
6. No visual or language impairment preventing understanding of study instructions.
7. Able to stand independently and walk at least 10 meters, with or without an assistive device.
8. Independent in basic activities of daily living.
9. Willing to provide written informed consent.
Healthy older adults:
1. Major neuromusculoskeletal disorders or injuries.
2. Severe cardiovascular, cerebrovascular, or psychiatric disorders.
3. Inability to cooperate with or complete study procedures.
4. History of allergy to surface electrodes.
5. Any other medical condition interfering with study participation or completion.
Older adults with knee osteoarthritis:
1. Neurological disorders.
2. Severe musculoskeletal or cardiovascular disease.
3. Severe lumbar disc herniation or major organ dysfunction.
4. Uncontrolled hypertension or diabetes.
5. Medical contraindications to exercise or inability to complete exercise or assessment procedures.
6. Beta-blocker use associated with exercise intolerance.
7. Recent smoking or alcohol abuse.
8. Inability to maintain the required squat position.
9. Visual impairment interfering with study procedures.
150
| 1st name | Ping |
| Middle name | |
| Last name | Liu |
Qufu Normal University
College of Physical Education and Sport Science
273165
No. 57, Jingxuan West Road, Qufu City, Shandong Province, China
+8613639443653
liu2578794@gmail.com
| 1st name | Ping |
| Middle name | |
| Last name | Liu |
Qufu Normal University
College of Physical Education and Sport Science
273165
No. 57, Jingxuan West Road, Qufu City, Shandong Province
+8613639443653
liu2578794@gmail.com
Qufu Normal University
Qingdao Municipal Bureau of Science and Technology
Local Government
Ethics Committee, Qufu Normal University
No. 57, Jingxuan West Road, Qufu City, Shandong Province
+8613639443653
liu2578794@gmail.com
NO
| 2026 | Year | 09 | Month | 29 | Day |
Not applicable
Unpublished
Not available
150
Of 150 randomized participants, 139 had post-intervention data. Significant population x treatment x time interactions were found for VAS, VL, RF, VM and BF muscle stiffness, and stand-up co-activation. In the KOA cohort, HILT reduced pain more than LLLT or sham. HILT increased selected muscle stiffness measures in healthy older adults but decreased them in KOA. No significant three-way interactions were found for WOMAC, tendon stiffness, squat-down or whole-cycle co-activation, BESS or YBT.
| 2026 | Year | 09 | Month | 29 | Day |
A total of 150 participants were enrolled, including 75 healthy older adults and 75 participants with knee osteoarthritis (KOA). Within each population, 25 participants were assigned to HILT, 25 to LLLT, and 25 to sham treatment. Baseline characteristics included age, sex, height, body weight, BMI, education, dominant limb, smoking, alcohol consumption, caffeine consumption, physical activity, VAS, and WOMAC scores. No statistically significant baseline differences were observed among the three treatment groups within either population for the assessed baseline characteristics.
A total of 150 participants were enrolled and randomized into six study groups, with 25 participants allocated to each group. Post-intervention data were available for 139 participants. In the healthy older adult cohort, 23 participants completed follow-up in the HILT group, 24 in the LLLT group, and 22 in the sham group. In the KOA cohort, follow-up data were available for 23 participants in the HILT group, 24 in the LLLT group, and 23 in the sham group. Overall, 139 of 150 participants completed post-intervention assessments.
No adverse events were reported during the 12-week intervention period. Participants were monitored for discomfort, excessive heat sensation, skin irritation, worsening pain, dizziness, falls, and other unexpected symptoms. No participant discontinued the study because of an intervention-related adverse event.
Outcome measures included pain intensity (VAS), knee-related symptoms and function (WOMAC), quadriceps and hamstring muscle and tendon stiffness assessed using shear wave elastography, quadriceps-hamstring co-activation during squat-down, stand-up, and whole squat-cycle phases, static balance (BESS), and dynamic balance (Y-Balance Test).
Significant Population x Treatment x Time interactions were identified for VAS, vastus lateralis, rectus femoris, vastus medialis, and biceps femoris stiffness, and stand-up phase muscle co-activation (all BH-FDR adjusted p < 0.05). No significant three-way interactions were observed for the remaining outcomes. The findings indicated outcome-specific and population-dependent responses to the laser protocols.
Completed
| 2024 | Year | 06 | Month | 01 | Day |
| 2024 | Year | 06 | Month | 01 | Day |
| 2025 | Year | 01 | Month | 15 | Day |
| 2025 | Year | 06 | Month | 15 | Day |
| 2026 | Year | 09 | Month | 29 | Day |
| 2026 | Year | 11 | Month | 19 | Day |
Value
https://center6.umin.ac.jp/cgi-open-bin/ctr_e/ctr_view.cgi?recptno=R000072231