| 基本情報/Basic information |
| 一般向け試験名/Public title |
事前指示書の作成支援のためのグループセッションの研究 |
Group-based education for advance directives and advance care planning |
| 一般向け試験名略称/Acronym |
事前指示書の作成支援のためのグループセッションの研究 |
Group-based education for advance directives and advance care planning |
| 科学的試験名/Scientific Title |
診療所における事前指示書作成支援のためのグループセッションの効果 |
Group-based educational intervention for advance care planning in primary care: a quasi-experimental study in Japan |
| 科学的試験名略称/Scientific Title:Acronym |
診療所における事前指示書作成支援のためのグループセッションの効果 |
Group-based educational intervention for advance care planning in primary care: a quasi-experimental study in Japan |
| 試験実施地域/Region |
|
| 介入/Intervention |
| 群数/No. of arms |
2 |
| 介入の目的/Purpose of intervention |
教育・カウンセリング・トレーニング/Educational,Counseling,Training |
| 介入の種類/Type of intervention |
|
| 介入1/Interventions/Control_1 |
ビデオとパンフレットでアドバンス・ケア・プランニングおよび事前指示書についての教育を行った。その後、介入群の患者は60分間のグループディスカッションに参加し、研究実施者のファシリテーションの元で、終末期医療の選好およびアドバンス・ケア・プランニングの意義について話し合った。ディスカッションセッションの後、主治医の定期外来が2回実施されるまでフォローアップを行い、主治医は患者の要請に応じて、アドバンスケアプランニングに関する質問に答えた。 |
An educational video and brochure on advance care planning and advance directives were offered to all participants in the study. Then, participants in the intervention arm attended a 60-minute group discussion with other participants, which was facilitated by one of the study investigators. The group discussion addressed preferences about medical care at the end of life and the purpose of advance care planning. After the discussion, the participants were tracked for a period of time during which two regular visits to their attending physician were made. Their physicians allocated time for answering questions about the advance care planning if it was needed. |
| 介入2/Interventions/Control_2 |
対象群の患者は、介入群と同じビデオとパンフレットによる教育の後、主治医と20分間の個別相談で、同様のトピックについて話し合った。ディスカッションの後には、介入1と同様の主治医によるフォローアップを実施した。 |
After watching the video, participants in the control arm engaged in a 20-minute individual discussion with their primary care physician on the same discussion topics. After the discussion, the follow-up visits were done in the same manner as those for participants in the intervention arm. |
| 介入3/Interventions/Control_3 |
|
|
| 介入4/Interventions/Control_4 |
|
|
| 介入5/Interventions/Control_5 |
|
|
| 介入6/Interventions/Control_6 |
|
|
| 介入7/Interventions/Control_7 |
|
|
| 介入8/Interventions/Control_8 |
|
|
| 介入9/Interventions/Control_9 |
|
|
| 介入10/Interventions/Control_10 |
|
|
| 適格性/Eligibility |
| 年齢(下限)/Age-lower limit |
|
| 年齢(上限)/Age-upper limit |
|
| 性別/Gender |
男女両方/Male and Female |
| 選択基準/Key inclusion criteria |
状態の安定した慢性疾患ために、研究実施施設に定期通院している65歳以上の患者を対象とした。患者は、決まった主治医に対して3回以上の通院歴があり、自分自身で意思決定が可能なものとした。 |
Eligible participants were adult patients aged 65 years or older who regularly visited an assigned physician in the trial site for chronic illness care. They were required to have seen their physicians more than three times and to be legally competent. |
| 除外基準/Key exclusion criteria |
過去に事前指示書やリビングウィルを記載している場合。また、当該の主治医以外にも、科を問わず、かかりつけの医師を持っている場合。 |
Those who had already completed advance directives or living wills were ineligible for this study. Those who regularly visited another physician of any specialty were also excluded. |
| 目標参加者数/Target sample size |
100 |
| 結果/Result |
| 結果掲載URL/URL related to results and publications |
https://jglobal.jst.go.jp/detail?JGLOBAL_ID=201402225778227537&rel=1#%7B%22category%22%3A%220%22%2C% |
| 組み入れ参加者数/Number of participants that the trial has enrolled |
109 |
| 主な結果/Results |
事前指示書の作成率はグループ群85.7%、個別群80.4%で、有意差を認めなかった(p=0.45)。これに比し、介入後の家族との相談率はグループ群20.7%、個別群21.7%と共に低く、有意差も認めなかった。グループ群の患者は、個別群の患者に比べて介入への満足度がわずかに高く(5点満点中4.2点、3.9点)、統計学的優位差を認めた(p=0.023)。 |
Advance directive completion rates were high for both group and individual arms but did not significantly differ between arms (85.7% vs. 80.4%, p=0.45). Only one-fifth of patients in both arms discussed advance care planning with their family after the intervention (20.7% and 21.7%, p=0.89). Patients in the group arm rated their experience slightly higher than those in the individual arm (4.2 and 3.9 out of 5, p=0.023). |
| 主な結果入力日/Results date posted |
|
| 結果掲載遅延/Results Delayed |
|
| 結果遅延理由/Results Delay Reason |
|
|
| 最初の試験結果の出版日/Date of the first journal publication of results |
|
| 参加者背景/Baseline Characteristics |
参加者の平均年齢はグループ群76.1歳、個別群78.8歳だった。大半は自分の健康を良いまたはとても良いと答えた(88.8%、73.9%)。介入前に事前指示書を知っていると答えたのは各群11.5%、13.0%だった。 |
Participants' mean age was 76.1 in the group arm and 78.8 in the individual arm. Most of them perceived their health status as good or excellent (88.8% and 73.9%, respectively). Only 11.5% and 13.0% of the participants in each arm were familiar with advance directives before the intervention. |
| 参加者の流れ/Participant flow |
合計133名の研究に適合した高齢者に参加を依頼した。109名は参加に同意し、63名がグループ群に46名が個別群に割り付けられた。割り付け後、各群から3名と2名はディスカッションセッションに参加しなかった。また、各群から3名と9名は介入後の事後評価の調査票に回答しなかった。 |
A total of 133 eligible older adults were invited to participate. Of them, 109 agreed to participate, with 63 assigned to the group arm and 46 to the individual arm. After the allocation, three and two participants in the group and individual arms, respectively, did not attend the discussion session, and three and nine, respectively, did not complete the second questionnaire after engaging in their allocated discussion session. |
| 有害事象/Adverse events |
なし |
None |
| 評価項目/Outcome measures |
事前指示書作成
家族との相談
アドバンス・ケア・プランニングの支援に対する満足度
アドバンス・ケア・プランニングに対する態度
|
Advance directive completion
Familial discussions
Satisfaction with the discussion sessions
Perceptions and attitudes about advance care planning |
| 個別症例データ共有計画/Plan to share IPD |
|
|
| 個別症例データ共有計画の詳細/IPD sharing Plan description |
|
|